Doctors Can Uncover Drug or Alcohol Use With Just One Question: Study

Primary care doctors can discover whether patients are abusing drugs or alcohol by asking a single question, a new study finds.

Asking patients how many times in the past year they consumed five or more drinks in a day (for men), and four or more (for women) is just as effective as administering a longer screening questionnaire in uncovering alcohol dependence, according to Dr. Richard Saitz of the Boston University School of Public Health. Doctors can reveal drug dependence by asking, “How many times in the past year have you used an illegal drug or used a prescription medication for nonmedical reasons?” he said.

“We found that single questions may be useful in both screening and preliminary assessment” of substance-use severity, Dr. Saitz said in a news release. “Instead of extensive interviews or long questionnaires, which are a barrier to screening in primary care settings, this approach may make it much easier to identify and appropriately address unhealthy substance use.”

The study analyzed responses from 286 patients, Science Daily reports. The single alcohol question detected 88 percent of patients with alcohol dependence. The drug question detected 97 percent of patients with drug dependence, the article notes. The results were similar to those found with longer screening tests.

Current drug and alcohol screening tools generally range from three to more than 80 questions, with multiple response options, Dr. Saitz noted in the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs. If screening indicates a patient may have a problem with drugs or alcohol, the doctor may refer the patient to a specialist, programs such as Alcoholics Anonymous, drug treatment, or other follow-up treatment. Patients at lower risk may benefit from brief counseling, according to Dr. Saitz.

14 Responses

Leave your Response
    User Picture


    November 29, 2016 at 2:06 AM

    please please please help!!!!!! I’m terrified!!!!! My friend has a very bad infection on his shin that is way beyond the most painful thing he’s ever experienced. He has no insurance so he was hoping it would just go away but it’s getting much worse and painful. Alcohol and handfuls of ibuprofen are helping with the pain, but only a little. A friend of a friend of a friend gave him powdered heroin to help with the pain. Though extremely apprehensive, he tried it and it worked the best. So, he is now giving in to the unbearable pain and going to an ER for help (mostly due to the shame that he had to resort to illegal street drugs). So, my question is: once the ER admits him and runs the standard blood drug tests, will the doctors refuse to administer any kind of effective pain medication when they see he’s taken/abused a highly illegal and taboo drug? Because, really, what’s the point of having to wait hours in a horrible ER just to have to face a team of condescending health professionals (real or imagined?) Only to leave with ibuprofen?

Leave a Comment

Please leave a comment below to contribute to the discussion. If you have a specific question, please contact a Parent Specialist, who will provide you with one-on-one help.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *